Top 5 Best Ice Cream Shops in Key West

1.Wicked Lick Ice Cream (Score 21): 335 Duval Street

Experience ice cream alchemy at its finest! Wicked Lick uses liquid nitrogen to create made-to-order scoops boasting unique flavors like Guava & Goat Cheese and Key Lime Pie Explosion. The vibrant Duval Street scene adds to the fun, making it a truly unforgettable sweet escape. (Vacation Uniqueness: 8, Cleanliness: 5, Taste: 8)

2. Gladiators Ice Cream (Score 20): 407 Front Street

Step into a gladiatorial arena of flavors at Gladiators! They champion classic and creative scoops, using only the freshest ingredients. Sink your teeth into their signature Honey Lavender or go bold with the Key West Rum Raisin. Don't forget to check out their rotating seasonal specials for a truly one-of-a-kind treat. (Vacation Uniqueness: 7, Cleanliness: 5, Taste: 8)

3. Kilwin's (Score 16): 505 Duval Street

Nostalgia meets indulgence at Kilwin's! Step back in time with their classic candies and fudge, then dive into their selection of homemade ice cream. Opt for traditional favorites like Chocolate or Vanilla, or sample something more adventurous like their Toasted Coconut or Mango Sorbet. (Vacation Uniqueness: 5, Cleanliness: 4, Taste: 7)

4. Haagen Dazs (Score 17): 425 Front Street & 625 Duval Street

Sometimes, familiarity is a comforting scoop. Haagen Dazs offers its well-loved classics in two convenient locations, perfect for satisfying a sudden ice cream craving. Indulge in your favorite pint flavors like Cookies & Cream or Belgian Chocolate, or try something new like their seasonal offerings. (Vacation Uniqueness: 2, Cleanliness: 9, Taste: 6)

5. Baskin Robbins (Score 13): 3124 N Roosevelt Blvd.

Baskin Robbins brings a world of flavors to Key West! With 31 choices rotating throughout the month, there's always something new to discover. Dive into their classic Butter Pecan or Strawberry Cheesecake, or explore more adventurous options like their Pralines & Cream or Mint Chocolate Chip. (Vacation Uniqueness: 1, Cleanliness: 6, Taste: 6)

Our Ice Cream Scoring System:

Vacation Uniqueness: Does the shop offer a one-of-a-kind experience you can't find anywhere else? (Higher score = more unique)

Cleanliness: Is the shop sparkling clean and hygienic? (Higher score = cleaner)

Taste: Does the ice cream live up to your expectations and tantalize your taste buds? (Higher score = tastier).