TOP 5 BEST COOKIE SHOPS IN KEY WEST

In our quest to find the best cookie spots in Key West, we've partnered up with Cookie Monster himself. With his iconic saying, "Me want cookie!". Additionally, we took into account the shop's overall deliciousness of their chocolate chip cookies. Our primary focus was on chocolate chip cookies, America's top cookie choice.

1. Double Tree Hotel (3990 S Roosevelt Blvd)

The cookies at the Double Tree Hotel are renowned for their irresistible taste. You don't need to be a guest to get your hands on a tin of these famous chocolate chip cookies. Double Tree Hotel has truly perfected the art of baking these warm, delicious treats, producing a staggering 30 million of these each year.

2. Publix (3316 N Roosevelt Blvd)

Publix has achieved something truly remarkable. Despite being a massive grocery store chain worth billions of dollars, they have managed to create one of the most mouthwatering chocolate chip cookies in Key West. This serves as a testament to the fact that even large corporations can learn from the creativity and expertise of smaller, local businesses.

3. Starbucks (2500 N Roosevelt Blvd)

You don't need a genius to tell you that coffee pairs well with a delectable all-butter cookie, filled with chocolate chunks that create a perfect blend of softness and crunchiness. It's hard to think of anything better than that!

4. Matthiessens Homemade Cookies (419 D. Duval St)

Large may be impressive for certain things, but when it comes to cookies, size falls short. A massive, one-pound cookie lacks the delightful taste, gooey texture, and satisfying crunch that make cookies truly enjoyable. Nevertheless, Key West vacationers do tend to rely heavily on visual appeal when it comes to their food choices!

5. Old Town Bakery (930 Eaton St)

Let's take a look at Old Town Bakery, a charming bakery that occupies a historic 19th-century structure. This establishment specializes in creating delectable pastries, breads, cookies, and pies, all made right on the premises. While their pies and breads are absolutely delightful, I must be honest with my readers and confess that their chocolate chip cookies leave much to be desired.